We've moved!
DakotaFreePress.com!

Social Icons

twitterfacebooklinkedinrss feed

Monday, January 4, 2010

Concealed Weapons Permits Hit Record in South Dakota

O.K., Osama, before you try anything funny here in South Dakota, I should point out that we are packing. Heat, that is. Secretary of State Chris Nelson reports South Dakota sheriffs issued a record number of concealed weapons permits last year, 16,907. That’s up 15.6% from 2008 and up 68% from 2005.

55,770 South Dakotans have concealed weapons permits. That means if you’re in a restaurant with 14 other South Dakotans, odds are 2 out of 3 that there’s at least one gun in the room. Make that a crowd of 50 South Dakotans, and there’s a 97% chance that at least one person is armed.

Funny: I thought that Obama fella was coming to take our guns. Full year in the White House, and he's not even counting them. Hmm... maybe that was the other fella....

But consider: if you think carrying a pistol around will make you safer, why hide it? Cops on the beat and Marines in Baghdad generally make no secret of their armed status. Wouldn’t a Smith & Wesson in full view on your hip send a much clearer “Don’t mess with me” message than a vague lump in your pants? Or is the idea of a concealed weapon to lure dopey bad guys in, get them to make the first move, and give you an excuse for live target practice?

I'm just asking. Commenters, fire away....

p.s.: Hankering for a little Wild West gunplay? Check this study by Robert McGrath of crime rates in gun-totin' Bodie, California, during the 1870s silver boom.

Death Penalty "Moral and Practical Failure"

The American Law Institute came up with the legal framework for the United States' modern system of capital punishment. Last October, the A.L.I. withdrew Section 210.6 on capital punishment from its Model Penal Code, citing "intractable institutional and structural obstacles to ensuring a minimally adequate system for administering capital punishment."

What's that mean? 4000 judges, lawyers, and law professors have declared that our system of killing certain bad guys is "irretrievably broken."

There just aren't any good arguments left for capital punishment. South Dakota, let's save money, save lives, and save ourselves the moral stain of killing criminals in captivity. Let's follow the A.L.I.'s lead and remove Chapter 23A-27A from our penal code.

-----------------------
Update 2010.01.05 15:55 CST: Mr. Feser links to a blog post by his pal Mike Gruszczynski expressing similar disgust with Nebraska's death penalty and the un-Christian hypocrisy that keeps it alive.

SD Media on Hyperion: Corporate Line Always Comes First

Mr. Epp reacts the same way I did to that Sioux Falls paper's headlining of some pro-Hyperion propaganda over the weekend. Hoping that most readers pay attention to only the first couple paragraphs, the mainstream media puts the corporate line at the top and shoves below the fold the copious evidence that Hyperion doesn't have a realistic chance of building its proposed Elk Point refinery.

But even below the fold, it's nice that the paid South Dakota press is catching up with what the South Dakota blogosphere has been pointing out for over a year: market fundamentals say Hyperion won't happen.

----------------------------
Update 2010.01.05 10:06 CST:
Cranky old Doug Maurstad picks up the theme with a good rundown of all the factors standing between Hyperion and a chance in heck of making their plans reality.

Vote in New Poll: Sunshine's Liquor Expansion Good for Madison?

You know I'm no fan of alcohol, but I want your opinion: will replacing Mr. Movies with an expanded liquor section at Sunshine/JubiShine be good for Madison? Register your answer to that question by voting in the newest Madville Times poll in the left sidebar.

You can look at the question from numerous angles. For instance, will the new liquor store...
  • ...increase jobs?
  • ...fulfill an unmet need for local consumers?
  • ...generate more sales tax revenue?
  • ...draw more out-of-town shoppers?
  • ...contribute to more alcohol-related problems?
  • ...decrease property values?
  • ...force competitors out of business?
  • ...hurt Madison's image?
Do your socioeconomic calculus, vote in the sidebar, and, if you like, explain your vote right here in the comment section. Tell your neighbors, and let's get a big sample on this one! Poll deadline is Monday, Jan. 11, at 6 a.m.

Why Minnesota Beats South Dakota: Taxes Invest in Public Goods

Reading (and questioning) the Small Business & Entrepreneurship Council's report on which states best conform to its ideological wishlist for policies that favor business reminded me of a report I cited a couple years ago in a discussion of South Dakota's upside-down tax system that taxes food but not gold. The latter report, by Dr. Robert G. Lynch, finds that the anti-tax, anti-government logic used by the SBEC to rank South Dakota #1 for entrepreneurship is flat wrong. Lynch argues that the public services provided by an adequate tax base add more value to the business climate than tax cuts that reduce public services:

Businesses need to know that they can rely on high-quality, well-administered public services to facilitate the conduct of their enterprises. Roads, bridges, and highways must be maintained in good repair; ports and airports must be large enough to handle transportation needs; sewage systems must be adequate to meet the needs of existing firms and expandable to service prospective businesses; snow removal and flood control must be reliable and timely; fire protection and police services must be ready when needed; the justice system must be professional, impartial, and quick to resolve contract disputes; and the schools and colleges must help to generate a skilled and well-trained workforce. A relatively crime-free state with high-quality public services—including good infrastructure and a highly educated workforce—will have an excellent business climate.

Minnesota, despite its relatively high business tax burden, is a good example of this. Compare Minnesota to its neighbor South Dakota, which has a relatively low business tax burden. As the Property Tax Study Project (2000) has noted, Minnesota has had higher per capita income after taxes, higher average hourly earnings, higher average annual pay growth, higher employment growth, more high school and college graduates per capita, better maintained roads and bridges, less income disparity, and a lower business failure rate than South Dakota. Indeed, Minnesota can be said to have a good business climate in part because of its relatively high tax burden, while South Dakota has a weaker business climate in part because of its relatively low taxes. Taxes are necessary to pay for the high-quality public services that make a state a good place to do business [emphasis mine; Robert G. Lynch, "Rethinking Growth Strategies: How State and Local Taxes and Services Affect Economic Development," Economic Policy Institute, 2004, p. 12].

Note that last part in bold: lower business failure rate. SBEC's argument is all perception; Lynch and I are looking at reality, actual business performance. Say what you want about how you think low taxes make a better business climate; when businesses fail at a higher rate in South Dakota than Minnesota, Minnesota clearly has the better business climate. The strategy of trying to attract businesses with tax breaks is likely to backfire:

...[I]t is unlikely that business decision makers are apt to be persuaded by “perceptions” rather than by the facts of business costs and benefits. In any case, firms that are driven appreciably by perception and are less attuned to the facts about costs and benefits are likely to be unsuccessful and few in number, as they tend to get driven out of business by their more savvy competitors. Attempting to attract such businesses by giving them tax breaks is probably not a wise investment on the part of state and local governments [Lynch, 2004, p. 11].

This EPI report is perfect counter-programming to the SBEC report. SBEC's chief economist Raymond J. Keating has a master's degree; Lynch is an actual Ph.D. Lynch and his fellow Ph.D. researchers at EPI get published in academic journals. SBEC is a right-wing advocacy group; EPI is a pro-labor group whose founders included reasonably intelligent former Secretary of Labor and fellow lefty Robert Reich.

As Dr. Lynch notes, we shouldn't always think of taxes as a "burden." They can be a way to save money... by subcontracting the government:

When tax cuts cause reductions in public services, firms may be forced to spend more on, for example, the education and training of their workers, health services for employees and their families, security for the workplace, and infrastructure. As a consequence, in the absence of adequate taxation, the provision of “public” services becomes an internal cost to firms. Moreover, the costs of providing these “public” services privately, in the relatively small amounts needed by individual firms, may be much higher than the costs of providing them collectively to all firms by government. For example, it may be cheaper for a city to provide police protection to all firms located within its borders than it would be for each firm to pay for its own security force. Thus, tax cuts and incentives may not reduce the costs of doing business but may, instead, contribute to rising costs by reducing publicly provided services [Lynch, 2004, pp. 5–6].

A business may not like paying taxes, but it would like hiring its own cops, teachers, and pavers a whole lot less.

Low-tax policy is a money loser for South Dakota in more ways than one. Consider that state and local taxes are deductible from federal income tax:

Typically, for every dollar of tax revenue lost by a state or local government due to tax cuts and incentives, firms increase their revenues by only about 60 cents. Due to the deductibility provisions of the tax law, the other 40 cents go to the federal government and other state and local governments in the form of higher tax payments. Ironically, therefore, state or local tax cuts and incentives subsidize competing jurisdictions by providing them with additional tax revenue [Lynch, 2004, p. 16].

So the next time you hear Governor Rounds or some right-wing advocacy group pontificating about how South Dakota's "low taxes" are good for business, tell them to look at reality in the form of Minnesota and Lynch's report.

Sunday, January 3, 2010

American Health Care: Spend More, See Doctor Less, Live Less Than Average

The best we can say about the wimpy health insurance reform bill Congress is the Tim Johnson line that it's a step in the right direction. But America's broken health care system will need a lot more steps to get to the real solution: real universal health care that gets people to the doctor before there's an emergency and without driving them to bankruptcy.

What's wrong with our system? Check this graphic from the National Geographic blog. It shows compares health care spending per person, annual doctor visits per person, and life expectancy in countries with universal health coverage (whether publicly or privately funded) and countries without.

The developed countries listed spend an average of just under $3000 per person on health care. Their citizens live to an average age of 79.2. There's no great American exceptionalism on life expectancy: we clock out at a respectable 78—although 45,000 of us die early each year because we lack insurance. But we distinguish ourselves in the other categories depicted in the graph. We are one of only two countries without universal health coverage—the other is Mexico. We go to the doctor less than everyone except the Mexicans, the Swiss, and the Swedes.

And what do we pay for less access to the doctor and shorter lives than the Portuguese? $7290 per person.

Who says Americans are smart shoppers?

-----------------------------
More notes on why health care reform won't be anywhere near done after the current bill passes:
  • 63% of staph infections in the U.S. are nasty antibiotic-resistant strains. Such cases cost us $6 billion and 19,000 lives a year. The Norwegians have figured out how to knock antibiotic-resistant staph infection rates down to 1%: require doctors to prescribe fewer antibiotics and isolate infected patients and staffers. It also helps to give workers paid sick leave and ban drug advertising.
  • From the same story, who's leading the way in the U.S. in fighting such infections? Government-run health care: VA hospitals have adapted the Norwegian model and achieved a 50% decrease in MRSA bloodstream infections.
  • Read Adam Geller's AP report on Remote Area Medical's efforts to bring free medical care to some of our fellow Americans whom we would otherwise leave to suffer and die. Read it, then go look RAM founder Stan Brock or his patients in the eye and tell them America has the best health care in the world.
-------------
Update 2010.01.04 10:50 CST: See also this graphic of America's status as the outlier on wasteful health care spending (Andrew Gelman, via Decorum Forum).

Update 2010.01.05 10:10 CST: Make that $7700. That's how much Americans spent per person on health care in 2008.

Review: Palin Book Lacks Intelligence, Analysis, Wit, Realism

I cite, without editorial comment, the review of citizen Sarah Palin's Going Rogue, newly posted by my friend and new Bard of White Owl Mr. Matthew J. Trask of Hubba's House:

...[Going Rogue] displays no intelligence, no analysis, no wit, and no realism. I really hate to say this, but it’s Chicken Soup for the Political Soccer Mom’s Soul.

There are no grammatical errors or errors of syntax, no misspellings and the paragraphs and chapters all line up nicely. It’s an easy read, too easy, like a glossy happy sixth grade textbook. I have read Civil War era “Lost Cause” treatises that were more realistic than this. It’s “rah rah go Alaska/America” with pedantic descriptons of Alaskan scenery, a few brief gushing sentences on Alaskan historical figures (William Seward,) and the most generic of quotes scattered here and there. For nuts on the fruitcake, we get the occasional unfunny soccer mom joke, not as in offensive, as in simply not funny [Matthew Trask, "Book Review: Going Rogue by Sarah Palin," Hubba's House, 2010.01.02].


Drop by Hubba's House to read the full review and leave your comments. Horseman, bibliophile, and imminent groom Mr. Trask is always happy to discuss literature and the affairs of this great nation.

Saturday, January 2, 2010

01022010... 20100102... Palindrome Day! Scream Real Loud!

Neighbor Rod Goeman points out the numerically cool nature of this fine winter day: it's a palindrome! Write the digits for today's date: 01-02-2010. Same forward and backward! Yahoo!

My numerically inclined European readers will have to wait until February 1 to celebrate, since they write the day before the month. But adopt my preferred ISO 8601 style (year.month.day), and you're the life of the palindrome party again: 2010.01.02. Same result! Abso-flippin'-lutely amazing! Party on, friends!

Bonus puzzler for readers not busy tobagganing: How many more palindrome days will we enjoy this century?

Brooks: Security Fails, Terrorists Succeed -- Grow Up, America

David Brooks is my kind of conservative. If you haven't read his critique of airport security and our expectation that we can legislate and technologize our way to perfect security, you should. He calls much of the criticism of the system that let the pants bomber board that plane in Amsterdam "contemptuous and hysterical":

Various experts have gathered bits of Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab’s biography. Since they can string the facts together to accurately predict the past, they thunder, the intelligence services should have been able to connect the dots to predict the future.

Dick Cheney argues that the error was caused by some ideological choice. Arlen Specter screams for more technology — full-body examining devices. “We thought that had been remedied,” said Senator Kit Bond, as if omniscience could be accomplished with legislation.

...For better or worse, over the past 50 years we have concentrated authority in centralized agencies and reduced the role of decentralized citizen action. We’ve done this in many spheres of life. Maybe that’s wise, maybe it’s not. But we shouldn’t imagine that these centralized institutions are going to work perfectly or even well most of the time. It would be nice if we reacted to their inevitable failures not with rabid denunciation and cynicism, but with a little resiliency, an awareness that human systems fail and bad things will happen and we don’t have to lose our heads every time they do [David Brooks, "The God That Fails," New York Times, 2009.12.31].

Brooks doesn't try to score political points: he offers equal criticism here for Republicans and Democrats. Everyone from Bush to Obama has bought into the notion that big government and big technology can solve all of our problems, and that if they produce anything less than perfect results, heads must roll.

Madison had 71 crimes over a four-month period, but we don't call for Chief Pulford's resignation or a complete overhaul of our "failing" police department. It's too bad we can't be similarly level-headed on airport security. A little British stiff upper lip might do more good than further investments in the diminishing returns of "Security Theater."

Top Ten Stories of 2010: A Madville Times Wishlist (Part II)

Read Part I here!

What will be the biggest news stories in 2010? Who knows? But here are five more stories I hope will be big news on the Madville Times:

6
Green Board Factory Coming to Madison: Mankato-based Environ Biocomposites broke ground on its newest facility in the Pitts Industrial Plaza on the southwest edge of Madison. The factory will employ 250 people making composite boards from locally crop waste like wheat straw and sunflower hulls. "We came to Madison because your blogosphere proved this is an area with some progressive thinkers," said EC VP Pete Tonsager. "That new bike trail on Mr. Pitts's land sealed the deal."

7
Dems Realize They Control Washington: In the face of apparent GOP election momentum, Congressional Democrats adopted a "make hay while the sun shines" attitude and passed several landmark laws, including the following:
  • the Franken-Weiner single-payer health care act;
  • an enhanced energy security act targeting a complete phase out of non-military domestic use of fossil fuels by 2030;
  • the Kucinich True Security Act, a permanent repeal of the PATRIOT Act;
  • the TARP retrofit, which imposed 79.9% interest on big corporate bailout recipients and redirected available funds to community banks.
Staying in Washington and working most of the year instead of campaigning helped Dems overturn pundit predictions and maintain their majorities in both houses of Congress.

8
Abortion Not an Issue in South Dakota Election: No news is good news: for the first time since 2004, the word abortion did not appear on the South Dakota general election ballot. Some pundits have suggested that this absence and the end of federal funds for abstinence education groups that have pushed past aboortion ballot measures was more than coincidence.

9
South Dakota Adopts State Income Tax: Governor Rounds signed HB 1776 into law, replacing every state tax with a flat 5% personal and corporate income tax. "We already have income tax on banks and farms," said bill sponsor Rep. Gerald Lange (D-8/Madison). "I figured why not be fair to everyone and simplify the whole tax code into one postcard?"

10
Keystone XL Pipeline Cancelled: TransCanada withdrew its application from the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission to build an oil pipeline across the western portion of the state following a district court ruling that TransCanada could not acquire land rights through eminent domain. The judge ruled the proposed Keystone XL pipeline did not meet the definition of "common carrier." TransCanada said acquiring the land through fair market negotiations would be "financially prohibitive." The pipeline already faced a doubtful future: investors have been pulling out of the dirty tar sands oil Keystone XL would have carried, and American gasoline demand has remained flat even as Obama economic boom accelerates.

Friday, January 1, 2010

Top Ten Stories of 2010: A Madville Times Wishlist (Part I)

Senator Snowe doesn't want to dwell on history, so why not look ahead with hope and aspiration? Here are the top ten stories of 2010. Don't confuse these headlines with predictions—in three previous tries, I have yet to pick a winner... although that's never stopped me before! These are just the ten best stories I hope I'll get to report on the Madville Times in the bright, bouncy new year.

1
Highway 34 Four-Lane Campaign Buys Masons' Building: "Build it and they will come," said campaign organizer John Goeman of Four for the Future members' decision to buy the Madison landmark. "We're sick of begging for federal money to build more road to Madison. We're going build something to give people a reason to come to Madison." Goeman and his colleagues have formed a non-profit corporation and hired local carpenters and artists to turn the old Masonic temple into a cooperative coffee house, gallery, meeting hall, and movie theater.

2
TSA Officers Work Naked: "I wasn't trying to start a revolution," said Chicago airport security agent Ralph Jablonski. "I just tell this lady to step into the body scanner, and she says, 'You show me yours and I'll show you mine.' So I says o.k., I drop my pants, and the lady steps right into the scanner, no questions asked. Pretty soon everybody in the airport's droppin' their drawers." Jablonski's initiative was so effective at improving customer satisfaction and trust, President Obama soon mandated nudity for all TSA staff. This new government transparency has inspired passengers to fly naked and made security a breeze.

3
Fahrenwald Named MadChestRut Superintendent: Following the resignations of their superintendents, Madison and Chester school districts both realized they could get along without a superintendent. "We farmed out duties to the principals and business manager, and no one noticed a difference," said Madison board president Jay Niedert. Madison and Chester then pursued further cost savings by taking up an offer from the Rutland school district: the two school districts dissolved and merged with the Rutland School District. Rutland Superintendent Carl Fahrenwald will run the new district, which spans three-quarters of Lake County. Madison residents responded with cautious approval: "Maybe now we'll win some football games," said former coach Tom Milne.

4
Jason Bjorklund Places Third in County Commission Race: Local 9-12 Project activist Jason Bjorklund came within two votes of winning a Lake County Commission seat in the November 2 election. Bjorklund's third-place finish was the closest any Glenn Beck/Tea Party candidate came to actually winning elected office on any South Dakota ballot. "I love politics!" said Bjorklund, vowing to run again. "I just need to keep improving my public speaking skills. I also need to remember that real county politics are about fixing roads and hiring good cops, not banning the Federal Reserve and preaching Natural Law."

5
Heidepriem Names Munsterman Economic Development Czar: After a literally bruising gubernatorial race that saw primary season fistfights and independent challengers splintering the state Republican Party, Governor-Elect Scott Heidepriem announced the olive-branch appointment of his main challenger, Scott Munsterman, as state economic development czar. "Scott knows South Dakota's future depends on promoting growth through cooperation in our rural communities," said Heidepriem. "Plus, the economic portfolio will keep Scott away from his nutty fundagelical friends in the all-abortion-all-the-time crowd."

...read on: here's the second half of the Top Ten Stories of 2010!

End South Dakota Investment in Terrorism

Pat Powers is right: this is an issue where we strip off the party labels and talk about doing the right thing.

Dakota War College spotlights a gross injustice in South Dakota's state investments. According to Powers, of the money we use to fund pensions for our state employees, 29% is invested with companies connected to terrorist states. Of 55 companies where we invest our money, 44 deal with Iran, 18 deal with Syria, 16 with Sudan, and 10 with Libya.

If you think President Obama is a menace for suggesting we talk with Iran, how do you feel about Pierre investing your money there?

Powers notes that the honchos of the state investment council and retirement system are pushing legislation to keep the Legislature from interfering with their investment decisions, even if those decisions are socially unsavory. He says State Rep. Dan Lederman is leading a group of legislators who will fight to get our money out of Iran.

Powers makes a clear call to all South Dakotans to get on board with terror-free investment of state dollars. I can't argue with that. Yes, social investing would create some more hassle for state investment officer Matt Clark. But he gets paid big bucks to do hard work like that. He also gets paid big bucks to do the will of the people of South Dakota. I suspect South Dakotans will agree that no marginal growth of our state investment fund is worth funding roadside bombs, political oppression, or genocide.

Keep an eye out for Lederman's bill... and morality in state investments.