We've moved!
DakotaFreePress.com!

Social Icons

twitterfacebooklinkedinrss feed
Showing posts with label deficit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deficit. Show all posts

Monday, December 13, 2010

Conservatives Already Seeing Through Kristi Noem Facade

All conservatives got with Kristi Noem was looks. Observers outside South Dakota are already seeing that, far from a true Tea Party crusader, Noem is just another pork-seeking farm-state politico. Take her comments on subsidies for ethanol:

Speaking on the Scott Hennen Show Noem says “Ethanol has been very good to South Dakota.” She said that this is not the time to repeal the subsidy “when you look at taking away that subsidy it is the wrong decision.”

She says that supporting the ethanol industry with subsidy promotes investment and continued hiring “In the long run it will get the economy back on track faster” [Kurtis Workman, "New South Dakota Congresswoman Say Ethanol Subsidy Good For Recovery," PlainsDaily.com, 2010.12.09]

Wait a minute: isn't Noem the same lady who spent a lot of time this year blasting federal stimulus efforts?

Let's tour the blogosphere. Rob Port at Say Anything:

How are ethanol subsidies any different than Obama’s economic stimulus spending? The fiscal conservative argument against the stimulus spending spree was that government cannot create jobs because government cannot spend anything without taking away from someone else.

Given that, if Obama’s stimulus spending hasn’t resulted in job growth (and we know it hasn’t) then how is spending on ethanol subsidies any different? [Rob Port, "South Dakota Rep. Kristi Noem: Ethanol Subsidies Are Economic Stimulus," SayAnythingBlog.com, 2010.12.09]

Rand Simberg:

This is depressing. Kristi Noem hasn’t even taken office yet, and she’s already defending home-grown pork as “stimulus"... [Rand Simberg, "And So It Begins," Transterrestrial Musings, 2010.12.11].

The Lonely Conservative from New York:

Kristi Noem is conservative only when it suits her.... I'm glad I didn't waste my time blogging about this woman ["Just When I Was about to Praise Kristi Noem," The Lonely Conservative, 2010.12.12].

Ah, but we shouldn't be too hard on our Mrs. Noem. She's just following the lead of John Boehner and the other big Washington Republicans who are engaged in the same hypocrisy on the pending $855 billion tax-rate and stimulus deal. Stimulus packages and deficit spending are bad, bad, bad when Democrats will get the credit and we need to rile up the voters. But when stimulus packages and deficit spending send money to our favored special interests, be they the ethanol industry or the richest 1% of Americans who pay for our campaign ads, then spending money we don't have becomes our patriotic duty.

Saturday, December 4, 2010

South Dakota, the Welfare State: Chapter 847

Say it again, kids: South Dakota loves federal money. South Dakota lives on federal money.
  1. The new Inter-Lakes Community Action Partnership building will be built on Uncle Sam's dime. Madison's city fathers cheerfully announced a $290K handout from the federal Community Development Block Grant program yesterday. The new office and Head Start facility has already received local subsidy in the form of a rock-bottom sale price for the land from the city.
  2. Heartland Conumer Power District general manager and DSU December commencement speaker Mike McDowell echoes Senator Max Baucus's complaint that the Simpson-Bowles deficit reduction plan asks rural communities to pay their fair share of the decades of debt we all have rung up. McDowell and Baucus don't want us to pay higher taxes on energy (where's McDowell work again?) or receive less in social programs for our relatively high numbers of veterans and senior citizens.
  3. Governor-Elect Dennis Daugaard's announcement of his latest cabinet appointments includes this tiny tidbit from Dennis:

    "I want to thank Kim Malsam-Rysdon for taking on this new role as Secretary of Social Services.... At a time when federal support is falling and economic conditions are increasing demands for services, leading this department is challenging."

    Catch that? Daugaard is grumbling that his Secretary of Social Services is getting less money from Washington. This just days after hobnobbing in Washington with Speaker-designate John Boehner, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, and other GOP leaders who insist government needs to shrink.
Maybe this is why the Tea Party has such piddly rallies in South Dakota. Maybe this is why Kristi Noem still plays so coy about being tagged as a Tea Party doll. Maybe they all realize what I've been saying all along: the Tea Party/Grover Norquist pablum about getting Uncle Sam off our backs is a prescription for fiscal and economic disaster in South Dakota. We are a welfare state. Dennis Daugaard and Kristi Noem are unlikely to change that.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Hunter: Simpson-Bowles Roadmap to National Unity

The deficit reduction plan proposed by Alan Simpson and Erskine Bowles rouses our man Hunter to comment on duty, shared sacrifice, and bringing Americans together (cue Lee Greenwood):

The all-encompassing approach [of the Simpson-Bowles plan] gives citizens the chance for all of us to contribute to fixing a problem that we caused ourselves. We're not going to create the problem and give it to our children. We're going to take responsibility.

This isn't symbolic patriotism like putting up a flag on the Fourth of July. This is real patriotism, where everyone sacrifices for the good of the country, for our future. We can use this crisis as an opportunity to unify our nation once again [Jon Hunter, "Deficit Panel Recommendations Could Actually Unify Americans," Madison Daily Leader, 2010.11.15].

Hunter may be right about the unifying effects of shared austerity. Calling for every American to pay more taxes and accept fewer services from Uncle Sam could give Americans a sense of common purpose. Involving everyone could make the plan itself work better, like when an overweight family diets together, or when a group of friends all choose to quit smoking together.

Simpson and Bowles propose a national austerity plan that would take 27 years just to balance the annual budget; that's a long -term campaign that could keep our national attention focused on a goal rather than on partisan politics for several election cycles. It challenges the Tea Party re-enacters to prove that they aren't just convulsing against President Barack Obama but really can live up to their rhetoric about our grandkids. If they can, we liberals might be able to find common cause with them, pay more taxes, accept cuts to programs we love, and work toward fiscal sanity.

As Bob the Builder says, Can we do it?
---------------------------------
If we can't unite around a plan, perhaps we can at east unite around a game. Neighbor John Nelson points me toward the New York Times' interactive checklist that lets each of us take a swing at reducing the deficit. I take a swing and prove that Simpson and Bowles are pikers: instead of waiting until 2037 to balance the budget, I run a $330-billion surplus by 2015. 50% spending cuts, 50% tax increases... with a $1.1-trillion surplus by 2030, I probably wipe out the federal debt by 2030. (Dang: I didn't even cut space-based missile defense.)

Robert Reich will probably jump in and say I also crash the American economy. Oops. Try your hand, and submit your results below!

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Simpson-Bowles Plan: No Magic Bullets, Just Long, Tedious Discipline

The co-chairs of the President's fiscal reform commission, especially former Republican Senator from Wyoming Alan Simpson, are straight-shooters who are done kissing butts to get elected. If anyone can propose strong medicine for the federal budget, these guys can. Yet even these relatively free radicals are proposing balancing the budget no sooner than 2037. Under their proposal, we keep borrowing more for 27 years. Now that's a disappointment.

Even these fiscal hawks acknowledge that the economy is too shaky to start their plan until FY 2012. In the whacky world of macroeconomics, America is too poor right now to cut its budget. We revert FY2012 spending back to FY2010 levels, cut 1% a year through FY2015, then allow spending to grow at 2% a year. If inflation runs at historical levels of 3.43%, then by 2040, our annual spending would be about 30% behind spending levels that would keep pace with inflation. That's a valuable change for our grandkids, but it takes long-term discipline to get there.

Where do we start with the cuts? Simpson and Bowles offer suggestions that hack $100 billion from defense and $100 billion from domestic spending. The big-ticket savings:

Defense:
  • Overhead savings proposed by Sec. Gates: $28 billion.
  • Reduce Pentagon procurement: $20 billion.
  • Freezing noncombat military pay at 2011 levels for three years: $9.8 billion.
  • Reduce overseas bases by one third: $8.5 billion (HS policy debaters! Check your Inherency arguments!)
Domestic:
  • Eliminate 250,000 contractors: $18.4 billion.
  • Eliminate all earmarks: $16 billion (even Rand Paul doesn't have the guts for this idea).
  • Freeze all federal pay for three years: $15.1 billion.
  • Cut federal workforce 10%: $13.2 billion.
More disappointment: the plan takes until 2040 to get the national debt down to 34% of GDP, just a little better than the 36% debt-to-income ratio recommended for regular folks shopping for mortgages. We spend the next three decades carrying more debt that responible homeowners ought.

The plan notes that right now, our federal outlays are 23.8% of GDP, while federal revenue is only 14.6% of GDP. The plan calls for aligning outlays and revenue by 2040 at around 21%. Look closely at those numbers: as I read it, for every dollar we reduce spending, we still need to raise revenue two dollars. The plan actually reduces and simplifies rates: one option drops the income tax rates for the top income bracket from two rates of 36% and 39.6% to one rate of 23% and reduces the corporate rate from 35% to 26%. But those decreased rates are contingent on whacking all deductions. Another option lowers rates less and leaves in some deductions, but cuts things like mortgage deductions for second homes and mortgages over $500k (oops: there goes the Lake Madison vote).

Other noteworthy recommendations in the Bowles-Simpson proposal:
  • Rein in health care costs by cutting payments to doctors and drug companies, capping malpractice damages, and possibly adding a robust public health insurance option.
  • Cut farm subsidies by $3 billion a year (good thing Kristi Noem just got a new job in Washington).
  • Keep Social Security solvent by increasing the retirement age by one month every two years, to age 69 by 2075, with a hardship exemption for folks who can't work after age 62.
Folks who thought electing Kristi Noem and her fellow Teabaggers would bring instant fiscal reform and wipe out the deficit are in for the same rude awakening as the handful of Obama dreamers who thought the 2008 election meant we'd reached the Promised Land. Fixing decades of fiscal irresponsibility will require decades of unpleasant spending cuts and increased tax collection. Given the cynical backpedaling of even the most arch of arch-conservatives and the inability of Tea Party faves to take their small-government slogans seriously (Kristi Noem has already pledged her continued support for the expensive Lewis and Clark water system), I am not optimistic that the new GOP majority in the House will take the Simpson-Bowles plan seriously. The Republicans are too focused on 2012 to lay the groundwork for real deficit reduction that will take until 2040.

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

Herseth Sandlin vs. Noem: Most Critical Issue, Least Critical Question

Part 7 of the Madville Times' South Dakota State Fair Congressional Debate analysis

The hosts of Sunday's debate—SD Corn Growers, American Coalition of Ethanol, East River Electric and SD Touchstone Energy Cooperatives—gave ag questions the spotlight before turning to other topics. Alas, out of several questions submitted by the packed house, the hosts chose this puffball: What is the most critical issue facing our country, and what will you do about it?

Come on, people. You might as well ask, "What's your stump speech?" or "What's the first paragraph on your website?" Use a debate to ask candidates the unexpected, to challenge their ability to think on their feet.

Oh well. We still got answers. Noem said the national debt. Herseth Sandlin said the economy.

Noem cited the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Admiral Mike Mullen to support her case. She said she decided to run in February while watching Congress pas a health care reform bill that we can't afford and that our children will pay for. Noem broke out numbers, saying the national debt has increased 39% since Obama took office. She said Congress should have to operate under a balanced budget requirement just like the South Dakota Legislature. She nicked Congress for failing to pass a budget resolution this year, the first time that's happened since 1974. And for good measure, Noem added that Congress is going into debt passing all sorts of programs that have no benefit for South Dakota. She said the stimulus promised South Dakota 10,000 jobs and instead we've lost 10,000 jobs.

Herseth Sandlin noted that the debt and clean energy are parts of the overall economic recovery problem. She then opened fire on Noem. She said Noem wants to have it both ways. Herseth Sandlin said Noem claims to support wind enegy but criticizes the stimulus, which has created 40,000 wind energy jobs. Herseth Sandlin said Noem blasts deficit spending but used those federal dollars three times to plug South Dakota's state budget gaps.

Herseth Sandlin defended the stimulus as necessary to counter the economy's downward spiral. The stimulus, she said, is about stabilizing the economy and making smart investments. She also challenged Noem's jobs numbers, citing the Sioux Falls Business Journal to say we've added 6200 jobs. Herseth Sandlin said Republican Governor Mike Rounds himself agrees that we've added jobs.

Herseth Sandlin concluded that she has the record on restoring pay-go principles, capping discretionary spending, and finding ways to pay for our priorities.

Assessment: As I said, it's a puffball question, so winning it doesn't add many points. Both candidates mustered numbers and clashed well. Had the organizers allowed rebuttal time, I'd have liked to have given Noem a chance to show her chops in listening and responding to her opponent's comments on the fly. Call this one even.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Thune's Paradox: 10% Cuts Never Eliminate Deficit; Debt Still Grows

When John Thune floated his "Deficit Reduction and Budget Reform Act of 2010," the Wonk Room noted that Thune's math was a bit off. His deficit reduction plan would create a joint committee, ten members from the House, ten from the Senate, equal numbers from each party (ah, spoken like a member of the minority) that would propose budget cuts to reduce the deficit by 10% every year.

Ever hear of Zeno's paradoxes? If you want to get to Hy-Vee, you first have to cover half the distance to the store. Then you have to cover half of the remaining half of the route. Then again, and again... nuts! You never get your grapes!

Ditto but worse with Thune's 10% plan. If enacted, his plan would chop the deficit down to 90% of the starting amount in year one, then 81%, then 72.9%.... We'd finally whittle the deficit down to less than 1% of the current amount by year 45 of the Thune plan... during which time the national debt would still have increased by an amount almost ten times the current annual deficit.

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Serious about Cutting Debt? End GOP Voodoo Economics

A new report from the Congressional Budget Office expresses concern (as ought we all) over continuing growth of our national debt-to-GDP ratio. The CBO appears to agree with something I said to Mr. Gibilisco the other day: sometimes you have to borrow money (e.g., wartime production, anti-recession stimulus), but the more you borrow, the less wiggle room you have for future spending. Bringing down the debt requires austerity programs that raise taxes and cut spending. CBO says such policy changes usually though not always "exacerbate... economic downturns." So odds are you have to pick what you want grumble about. If you don't like the recession, you might have to live with a growing debt for a few more months. If you don't like the debt and want austerity now, then brace for another downturn.

Austerity, alas, is a dirty word in American politics, which assumes a perpetual-motion machine of magic abundance. Conservatives are harping on the debt, but they don't want to take direct action to pay it down. The President comes up with a health care law that will save $8 billion on Medicare this year and $575 billion over the next ten, and conservatives fan fears among seniors that these cuts will mean Democrats want old folks to die. Conservatives instead want to leave most of the big spending (war, entitlement programs for senior voters) in place and cut taxes, thinking the debt will magically reduce itself.

Cutting taxes does a lot of things, but it doesn't reduce the debt, certainly not as a percentage of GDP. Check out the bumps around the time of the great Reagan and Bush tax cuts. Those bumps don't go downward:

CBO historic chart of national debt-to-GDP ratioFigure 1: U.S. Debt-to-GDP Ratio, historic.
Source: CBO report, p. 2. Click figure to enlarge.

David Stockman, who worked for President Reagan, agrees that the fiscal policy Republicans offer is a useless mess. Stockman finds it "unseemly" that Republicans respond to our mounting public debt with cries to extend the Bush tax cuts and spare the wealthiest Americans a three-percent tax increase. (CBO notes it would take a 1% increase in federal revenues to stop the growth of the debt-to-GDP ratio; a 3% increase would reverse that growth.) Stockman finds this shirking of fiscal responsibility particularly odious given that the wealthiest 1% amassed two-thirds of the economic gains from the 2002–2006 economic bubble.

Our debt situation is dire due not to drunken-spending Democrats but Republicans living in la-la-land, says Stockman:

This debt explosion has resulted not from big spending by the Democrats, but instead the Republican Party’s embrace, about three decades ago, of the insidious doctrine that deficits don’t matter if they result from tax cuts.

In 1981, traditional Republicans supported tax cuts, matched by spending cuts, to offset the way inflation was pushing many taxpayers into higher brackets and to spur investment. The Reagan administration’s hastily prepared fiscal blueprint, however, was no match for the primordial forces — the welfare state and the warfare state — that drive the federal spending machine.

Soon, the neocons were pushing the military budget skyward. And the Republicans on Capitol Hill who were supposed to cut spending exempted from the knife most of the domestic budget — entitlements, farm subsidies, education, water projects. But in the end it was a new cadre of ideological tax-cutters who killed the Republicans’ fiscal religion.

Through the 1984 election, the old guard earnestly tried to control the deficit, rolling back about 40 percent of the original Reagan tax cuts. But when, in the following years, the Federal Reserve chairman, Paul Volcker, finally crushed inflation, enabling a solid economic rebound, the new tax-cutters not only claimed victory for their supply-side strategy but hooked Republicans for good on the delusion that the economy will outgrow the deficit if plied with enough tax cuts [David Stockman, "Four Deformations of the Apocalypse," New York Times, 2010.07.31].

Stockman notes that under President GW Bush's last budget, federal revenue was just 15% of GDP, the lowest percentage since the 1940s. Once again, we see that cries of "Taxed Enough Already!" show ignorance of historical fact... and a thin-skinnedness that Grandma and grandpa would find shameful. And don't forget: those low taxes not only make the debt worse but also may be hurting the economy.

Let's trade the myths about the Bush tax cuts for reality. Right now, those tax cuts for the rich are responsible for about 25% of our annual deficit. Extend the Bush tax cuts, and they'll be responsible for around 50% of our deficit in 2019.

Make Grandma and Grandpa proud: end voodoo economics. End the Bush giveaways. Pay the bills.
---------------
Update 10:41 CDT: Robert Reich helps out with some useful facts.

Friday, July 16, 2010

Estate Tax Relief vs. Balanced Budget: Pick Your Priority

Republican candidate for U.S. House Kristi Noem tells South Dakotans she wholeheartedly supports balancing the federal budget. Noem also says she wants to get rid of the estate tax, a tax that impacts maybe 50 South Dakota families a year.

The woman whose job Noem wants, Congresswoman Stephanie Herseth Sandlin, has already helped House Dems pass estate tax relief for 99.75% of Americans. (That bill remains idle in the Senate.) Herseth Sandlin claims, like Noem, to be a big deficit hawk.

WaPo's Dylan Matthews breaks down the budget impact of various estate tax proposals and compares them with the extension of unemployment benefits. Writing checks to keep jobless folks' heads above water for another year—something Republicans keep sandbagging for political gain—adds a one-time $33-billion spike to the deficit. The chintziest estate tax reform, the House bill the SHS and President Obama support, increases the deficit every year and racks up around $300 billion in new debt through 2018. Ending the "death tax" completely (that's what Noem wants) adds more than $600 billion in deficit spending through 2018.

I look forward to hearing how much of Medicare, Social Security, and defense Noem plans to cut to offset her massive and irresponsible tax cuts... because she's not going to find $600 billion anywhere else.

-----------------
Update 2010.07.17: The Displaced Plainsman finds his place in this debate by pointing out that America's aristocracy doesn't need repeal of the estate tax: they already use trusts to evade it.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

"Taxed Enough Already?" So We Shouldn't Pay for What We've Bought?

Funny that for all their fretting about the public debt, the conservative crowd rarely advocates we take personal responsibility for all that debt. We hear accusations that high tax rates are destroying our liberty, yet we are shouldering a lower tax burden than the last couple generations. USA Today reports that federal, state, and local taxes eat up 9.2% of our total personal income, the lowest percentage since 1950. Over the last 60 years, the average tax bite of personal income has been 12%. (Say it with me: manufactured outrage.)

Some quick numbers:
  • Nationwide, our total personal income last year was just a hair over $12 trillion.
  • If the tax burden on that income were the 12% recent historical average, we'd kick another $337 billion toward our public debt.
  • Unfortunately, we have just under $17 trillion in public debt at the national, state, and local levels.
Without some serious budget reform, we may add almsot a trillion dollars to the federal debt every year this decade. Uff da.

But what are we spending that money on? Check out this graphic:

U.S. Federal Budget Deficit Drivers through 2020
Right now, the recession, the bailout, and the stimulus are responsible for about 60% of our deficit. But the bailouts are wrapping up and putting cash back in the kitty. The stimulus runs out next year (which is the first thing every South Dakota legislative and gubernatorial candidate should be talking about). Heck, we might even get out of Iraq and Afghanistan. For most of the coming decade, the single biggest deficit driver will be the Bush tax cuts—i.e., our unwillingness to pay for the fighter jets, border patrol agents, Medicare drug benefits, and other goodies that we all love and that not one serious candidate for South Dakota's lone House seat is willing to part with.

Candidates can talk all they want about reducing government. We still have to pay the bills we've already racked up. And current tax rates suggest we are all shirking our responsibility to pay for what we've used.

If you're serious about eliminating the national debt, step one is to let the Bush tax cuts expire... unless, of course, you can identify $693 billion to remove from the annual budget by 2019.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Conservative Economists to Deficit Hawks: Put a Sock in It, for Now

Contrary to the opinion of our South Dakota House Republicans and some crotchety conservatives in D.C., the stimulus act really is "important, useful, and beneficial" for our fair state and the whole country. Jim Bunning be darned, extending unemployment benefits really is a good idea:

Almost every economist agrees that these benefits do, indeed, stimulate the economy by putting money into the hands of people likely to spend that money immediately [Matthew Blake, "Unemployment Benefits Are Economic Stimulus," Understanding Government, 2010.03.09].

Economists think that? Really?

Yes, even the conservative ones:

Few observers, for example, would accuse David M. Walker of being a liberal spendthrift. Indeed, the former U.S. comptroller general has spent most of the last decade forging a personal crusade against deficit spending. Yet last week — on the same day that Bunning, a Hall of Fame baseball pitcher known more for his curveball than his economic insights, initiated his drive against fiscal imprudence — Walker wrote in Politico that “a focus on jobs now is consistent with addressing our deficit problems ahead.”

“A huge recession can yield a huge deficit,” Walker, now head of the Peter G. Peterson Foundation, which advocates for balanced budgets, wrote in an op-ed co-authored by Lawrence Mishel, president of the liberal Economic Policy Institute. “Though a concern, most of the recent short-term rise in the deficit is understandable. Furthermore, public spending can help compensate for the fall in private spending, and help stem the pain of substantial job losses.”

Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Economy.com, agrees. Zandi, an adviser to Sen. John McCain during the Arizona Republican’s 2008 run at the White House, has urged lawmakers in recent weeks “to be aggressive” in tackling the continuing jobs crisis, which has left nearly a fifth of the nation’s working population without a job or underemployed.

“If we have another recession, we will have no policy response,” Zandi told a House panel last week. “We have to err on the side of doing too much.”

The message from the experts is clear: If you think adding $10 billion to the deficit is dangerous to future economic growth, wait ‘til you see what happens when millions of unemployed folks, denied access to a government safety net, slash their consumption (at best) and foreclose on their homes (at worst) [Mike Lillis, "GOP’s Deficit Crusade Faces Opposition From Fiscal Hawks," Washington Independent, 2010.03.04].

Now maybe you still think the stimulus package and unemployment benefits are bad. Maybe you think we should throw the brake and stop all deficit spending. Go ahead, candidates (R. Blake? Kristi?), advocate that... and also advocate up front driving us right back into a recession that will outlast anyone's term limits in the South Dakota Legislature.

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Alan Simpson Does Politics Right -- Listen Up, Obama & Dems!

Among the good things about President Obama's creation of a committee to study the deficit: his selection of Republican straight-shooter and former Wyoming Senator Alan Simpson to chair the commission with Erskine Bowles. How does Simpson plan to tackle the deficit?

There are a lot of bitchers and whiners and snorters out there, and we intend to listen to them all, and then crush them.

—Former Senator Alan Simpson, interviewed on NPR, All Things Considered, 2010.02.18

Dang! If President Obama would start laying down the law the way Senator Simpson does, he'd defy ex-VP Cheney's one-term prediction for sure.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Blame Deficit on Recession, Russ Olson, LAIC, You, Me....

David Montgomery earns his pay this week with a great blog post on how much of the 2009 deficit can be attributed to Bush and how much to Obama. The short breakdown: Bush is responsible for $600 billion, Obama $350 billion, and the recession $420 billion (economy slowed down, government received less revenue). Montgomery's post gives some useful numbers to deflate Senator Thune's facetiously false claim that Bush's final budget "ran a deficit of just over $400 billion."

Meanwhile, Madison's own Jon Hunter grumbled a bit last week about the proposed (and now rejected) bipartisan deficit commission. Hunter grumbled that we don't need a committee to study a problem that we all recognize and know how to solve. Hunter also expressed his pessimism about the prospect of the Administration or Congress actually doing anything about that problem.

Missing from Hunter's grumbling was any mention of the plank in our own eye. Certainly deficits will continue as long as politicians keep promising pork and subsidizing corn and taking us to war without passing taxes to pay for them. but our politicians will keep doing that as long as we keep asking them to. Among the local deficit drivers among us whom Hunter neglected to include in his complaint:
Go ahead, wag your finger at the people responsible for our deficit. Just be sure to do it while looking in the mirror.

Sunday, December 27, 2009

Republican Hypocrisy: Deficit Spending Great for 2003 Medicare Drug Benefit

One of the main arguments the Republican obstructionists (and their Blue Dog Democrat helpers) offer against health care reform is that the trillion-dollar program would increase the deficit. You can argue the numbers, but the Democrats have clearly tried to cobble together spending cuts and tax increases to offset the costs.

Compare this to 2003, when the Republican majority in Congress passed the half-trillion-dollar Medicare prescription drug benefit and funded it 100% with deficit spending. 24 current GOP Senators voted for that massive increase in the deficit.

One of those erstwhile big spenders, Senator Olympia Snowe from Maine, now says, "Dredging up history is not the way to move forward." Funny—I thought dredging up history was the way to move forward without repeating past mistakes (even if Santayana didn't say it).

Well, at least it took just six years for Republicans to get religion on deficit spending. It's too bad they couldn't have learned it during eight years of Bush rule. (Debt when George W. Bush took office: $5.7 trillion. Debt when he left: $10.6 trillion.) I just wish I could believe their newfound deficit-hawkishness is more than a smokescreen for a lack of ideas and a convenient anti-Obama political posture, which they will shed the moment they are back in the position of actually governing and making hard fiscal choices.

At least Senator Thune can claim immunity from this hypocrisy: in 2003, he was busy working as a lobbyist.

Saturday, October 3, 2009

Robert Reich: Don't Worry, Be Happy... and Bring Back the WPA

Those of you conservatives who just woke up from eight years of Bush-induced deficit-opposition deficit disorder (and those rare birds among you who consistently criticize deficits even when there aren't Dems in the White House) should read Robert Reich's call for more, not less, federal spending:

Let me say this as clearly and forcefully as I can: The federal government should be spending even more than it already is on roads and bridges and schools and parks and everything else we need. It should make up for cutbacks at the state level, and then some. This is the only way to put Americans back to work. We did it during the Depression. It was called the WPA.

Yes, I know. Our government is already deep in debt. But let me tell you something: When one out of six Americans is unemployed or underemployed, this is no time to worry about the debt [Robert Reich, "The Truth About Jobs That No One Wants to Tell You," Robert Reich's Blog, 2009.10.01].

But can we really get by with spending for the moment and not thinking about the future? What about our grandkids?

Reich is not just whistling happy tunes. Reich is pointedly mindful of future generations, and he offers an empirical example to show more spending could be the best thing we can do for them:

When I was a small boy my father told me that I and my kids and my grand-kids would be paying down the debt created by Franklin D. Roosevelt during the Depression and World War II. I didn’t even know what a debt was, but it kept me up at night.

My father was right about a lot of things, but he was wrong about this. America paid down FDR’s debt in the 1950s, when Americans went back to work, when the economy was growing again, and when our incomes grew, too. We paid taxes, and in a few years that FDR debt had shrunk to almost nothing.

I know a trillion-dollar deficit is a big scary thing. It's easy to pin all your fears of that man in the White House on that one overwhelming number and the easy rallying cry of "What about our children?!" I'm even willing to entertain serious suggestions to eliminate the deficit and the debt by shutting down Medicare, Medicaid, and the military... which is what you'd have to do, for ten years, to pay off the national debt. (Feel free to peruse the federal budget and come up with your own debt-elimination strategy.) Who needs jobs and economic growth, right?

But if you accept the premise that economic recovery is essential to the fiscal viability of the government (not to mention pills for Grandma and bullets for G.I. Joe), you need to put down your signs, get on board with Reich, and let the government do what the private sector apparently cannot.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Sleep Well, Says Robert Reich: Deficit No Big Deal

Worried the deficit is too big? Robert Reich (no ignorant fellow) says don't worry, it's nothing:

Second, deficits and debts mean just about nothing anyway -- at least out of context. In 1945, the federal debt was 120 percent of the entire U.S. economy. Yeegads! Yet only a few years later, the debt as a proportion of GDP had been tamed -- and not primarily because of cuts in government spending. Yes, of course, wartime spending ended. But the big change was in the denominator of the equation. Economic growth kicked in big time, and reduced the debt as a proportion of the economy to manageable levels [Robert Reich, "Don't Succumb to Deficit Hysteria," Robert Reich's Blog, 2009.08.25].

As a matter of fact, Reich actually thinks the deficit needs to be bigger. I kid you not: with the economy still sluggish, Reich says we need to pour on more government spending to get people back to work. Uff da! Sing yourself to sleep with that one, and tell me what you think in the morning!