We've moved!
DakotaFreePress.com!

Social Icons

twitterfacebooklinkedinrss feed
Showing posts with label values. Show all posts
Showing posts with label values. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Bringing Religion to the Polls: How High Is Your Wall?

As I enjoy the tense hush surrounding a free people somberly performing their sacred democratic duty, I muse over seemingly conflicting views of politics and religion from theologically inclined corners of the South Dakota blogosphere.

First, check out the Gordon Howie/Pastor Scott Craig show at The Right Side Blog. Their mission statement calls for stimulating something called "Christian Conservative thought." In the last week and a half, their posts have portrayed this election as a "wake-up call for Christians." They have portrayed voting as a moral imperative to address the "dive" of the "moral fabric of our country" that is "apparent to every Christian." Under patriotic images of the American flag and Founding Fathers, they have exhorted readers to "take a stand for God and Jesus" (the ending D and S should be pronounced as separate syllables) the way the Founding Fathers did by doing "something." They urge voters to subject candidates to religious litmus tests. They even feature Rep. Mike Verchio (R-30/Hill City) managing to conflate Christian principles with tax and spend policies and his right to defend himself.

Meanwhile, another Christian, Pastor Shel Boese, offers this thought on Election Day:

As we approach another election in the USA I am so thankful our founding fathers understood that the church is best protected by not being co-opted by the state. (Something many Evangelicals who are almost back into the Egypt of Fundamentalism forget) AND the State is healthier when the church can be a prophetic voice and alternative power source in the world/nation – instead of a co-opted branch of the statist machinery [Pastor Shel Boese, "Election Thoughts...1," News, Thoughts, Theology, Teaching..., 2010.11.01].

Tell me if I'm wrong (I know you will!), but I think Pastor Shel is saying something different about church and state than are Pastor Scott and his friends.

Be a prophetic voice... remember that, pastors, next time you benedict the mayor's prayer breakfast. Regardless of who sits in the governor's chair or our seats in Congress, perhaps Christianity calls believers to always be the loyal opposition.

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Fund Education... Not Root Beer Floats for Merely Tolerable Behavior

I wanted to get excited about an article in this morning's Rapid City Journal about Walmart and Sam's Club giving away $100 gift cards in their Teacher Rewards program. The Walton empire is handing out $4.5 million to teachers this year to offset the estimated $500 that American teachers spend out of their own pockets on their students.

"Ah ha!" I thought. "Here's an example of how spending less at the state level doesn't save any money but only transfers costs off the budget and tax rolls and into the less visible column of individual spending." Take 8000 teachers in South Dakota (that's a low estimate), multiply by $500... that's four million dollars in public expenditure shifted to the workers hired to provide the service.

Now Walmart isn't making up the entire difference or handing gift cards to every teacher. Last week, the local Sam's Club gave ten teachers at Rapid City's South Park Elementary each $100 gift cards, intended for supplies or nutritious snacks for the kids (the kind of thing you can buy in big bulk packages at Sam's Club).

But then one teacher dampens my enthusiasm for this conversation by spending $45 of her gift on the following "educational" expense:

[Fifth-grade teacher Hollie] Hoffman has been teaching for seven years and likes to use incentive parties to motivate or to reward good behavior. On Friday, her class got root beer floats because, during the month of September, all students had less [sic] than three behavior demerits and fewer than five late assignments [Mary Garrigan, "Rapid City Teachers Reach into Own Pocketbooks to Reach out to Students," Rapid City Journal, 2010.10.05].

I guess I really am out of touch with pragmatic modern teaching. I cringe at the thought of handing out treats and throwing parties for students just because they've managed to behave themselves most of the time. And the standards in Hoffman's classroom are apparently pretty low: the kids can be late on homework once a week and still get root beer praise.

That's reason #847 we're homeschooling for as long as we can. We need to get kids back into the mindset that learning and behaving are their own rewards, that there are things we're just supposed to do, not because we'll get praise and goodies but because they are the right things to do.

I balk at this sort of bribery even as an employee. During my three abominable months working in a call center, management picked some arbitrary sales-to-leads ratio and said if we beat it, the company would buy us all tickets to a ski lodge and lots of booze. That was when it hit me that the work I was doing had no real value in itself... and that I wanted out.

I am relieved that Principal Rick Owen at Rapid City's Pinedale Elementary says public funds are strictly allocated for educational expenses, not pizza parties. And Hoffman says she spends her out-of-pocket money on her kids "because I want to, not because the district funds are so inadequate."

Well, that's a relief, because when teachers feel the need to bribe kids into nominally decent behavior, we have a problem with something other than funding in our education system.

Sunday, September 5, 2010

Noem Spins Irresponsible Behavior as Virtue

I've thought that Kristi Noem's lengthy criminal record—skipping court six times, earning two arrest warrants—is a sign of either complete irresponsibility (Court date? Oopsies! Forgot again! Tee hee!) or sheer arrogance (What? You expect me to go to court? Do you know who I think I am?)

Noem's comments on Weekend Edition Sunday this morning convince me all the more it's arrogance. NPR's Brian Naylor asks Noem about her lengthy record of court-dodging and arrest warrants. She not only ignores those violations, but she tries to dress her unsafe driving up as virtue:

My nature has always been to be in a hurry and to try to get things done, and that's obviously something I need to work at when it comes to my driving record [Kristi Noem, interviewed by Brian Naylor, "Political Pedigree No Longer Protects S.D. Rep," NPR Weekend Edition Sunday, 2010.09.05].

Wow. The gall. Princess Kristi is just trying so hard to get things done, she can't be bothered with something so trivial as a court date. She says she needs to work on her speeding, but she never says she is working on it. She portrays her risky behavior as "her nature," as if it is something beyond her control.

This isn't hard, Kristi. When you're behind the wheel, you don't speed. When you get a ticket, you pay it. When the judge says come to court, you come to court. Quit trying to dress up your problem as "nature" or some noble effort to "get things done" and be responsible. Responsibility is a choice, the kind of choice you Republicans expect of everyone else.
--------------------
Update 2010.09.06: Gee, ignoring the law really is a Noem family value:

It isn’t that uncommon in Noem’s family, based on court records since 1989. Noem’s husband, Bryon, had 18 recorded traffic citations during that period, 11 of them for speeding. Noem’s brother, Rock Arnold, had 34 citations during that period, 25 of them for speeding. He also missed court or fine payment dates four times and had warrants issued three times. Another brother, Robb, had 21 citations, including 12 for speeding.

And Noem’s mother, Corinne Arnold, had 11 citations, nine for speeding [Kevin Woster, "Noem Apologizes for Traffic Citations," Rapid City Journal, 2010.09.05].

Sunday, June 6, 2010

David Astin PAC Does Karaoke, Impressions, Smear Campaigns

I can live with the fundagelical wingnuts doing their Limbaugh/Beck karaoke in the car and at their little meetings. If it makes you feel good to mouth the rhetoric fed to you by talk radio and World Net Daily and hear it echoing in your own head, then go ahead, knock yourselves out.

But when that karaoke goes public and starts spreading lies about good people, the wingnuts need a whoopin'... or at least a reasonable refutation.

That's what Curtis Price does as he responds to the wingnuttery of self-styled family-values crusader David Astin of Hermosa, whose "Family Matters PAC in South Dakota" has mailed out a big pink postcard attacking Equality SD as an extremist group pushing an agenda of deviance and oppression. The accusations are pretty much the same tired text Astin used to attack District 33 state senate candidate and Democrat Dennis Finch in the 2008 election.

On the latest FMPACinSD campaign finance report, Astin lists a Gmail address of "inquisitiveminds." Gee, maybe if Astin really had an inquisitive mind, he'd have been able to cite for reporter Kevin Woster some examples back in 2008 of how Finch supports the kinds of laws Astin shouts about on his lying postcards. Astin could only substantiate his wild accusations with the (Woster's words) "impression he got from reading the Equality South Dakota website."

Really, Mr. Astin, I hope you've stopped doing impressions and can come back with some actual research and examples on your current smear campaign.

FMPACinSD had a whopping $203 on hand last month. (When you have less money than the Lake County Dems, you're really wimpy.) FMPACinSD has reported no donations this year. I'd like to cite that as evidence that the usual right-wing "family values" distractions aren't playing this year in the face of the economy, education, and other issues that really are the government's business.

But FMPACinSD's lack of donations is more an indication that they aren't really a PAC. They are hardly a they. They are David Astin, spewing his insecure and hateful publications on his own dime. Since the PAC's inception in 2006, Astin has received $452.19 in unitemized contributions versus the $3475 of his own money poured into securing his own intolerant worldview with deceitful rhetoric.

By the way, pastor's son Astin doesn't appear to have a website for his PAC yet... but another more tolerant and tolerable SD Family Matters already exists... and appears to be doing more to protect real families than Astin's propaganda.

---------------------
Maybe related: political karaoke progenitor Rush Limbaugh is supporting family values by getting married for the fourth time. Of course, the Lord will likely strike down this relationship as he did Limbaugh's previous three marriages due to the presence of notorious homosexual Sir Elton John, whom Limbaugh paid $1 million to sing at the reception.

---------------------
Update 2010.06.09: Casey Murschel in District 12 says she got whacked by what sounds like the Astin PAC attack. Yuck!

Saturday, March 13, 2010

Brothers' Keepers: Cognitive Dissonance in American Health Care

So I'm reading Diffusion of Innovations by Everett Rogers, a classic text on how technology and ideas spread. Rogers presents a case study about "The Daughter-in-Law Who Doesn't Speak," a labor-saving contraption introduced in a Malian village. The women of the village each pay a small fee to use the Diesel-powered machine to perform tasks like grinding grain and nuts, sawing wood, and pumping water. The time they save—corn-pounding that took three days takes the machine just fifteen minutes—frees the women and girls to go to school and start businesses. Even the men dig all this liberation, as their wives have more spare time and softer hands.

Rogers notes that the practical advantages of the machine weren't the only reason it caught on. Innovations also need to be compatible with existing knowledge and values:

The new machine is too expensive for any single person in the village to afford it, but the Sanankoroni Women's Association, once formed, served to foster collective efficacy among the village women. The notion of collaborative associations of women to accomplish some action that they could not achieve individually is compatible with West African village values and with past experiences. So the innovation of The Daughter-in-Law Who Doesn't Speak was highly compatible with West African village life, as well as having considerable relative advantage [Rogers, E.M., 2003. Diffusion of Innovations, 5th Edition, New York: Free Press, p. 248].

An innovation catches on because it is compatible with local values, in this case with a belief in collective efficacy.

And my brain jumps to American health care. (Yes, it's quite exciting living in my brain.) I wonder if America remains the last bastion of resistance to national health care in the industrialized world because we reject the idea of collective efficacy, the idea that we can do things better as a group than we can as individuals.

Wait: we do believe in collective efficacy. Right now, the vast majority of Americans do not pay for their own health care. Almost no Americans can: almost anything beyond a routine checkup costs more than we can afford out of pocket. So we chip in and pay for each other's health care. Since our daughter was born, my wife and I have paid over $10,000 in health insurance premiums that have almost gone almost entirely to cover other policyholders' medical expenses. We've paid into Medicare to help cover health care costs for my dad and millions of other old folks.

Odds are, so have you. If your employer offers health coverage, your and your employer's contributions pay not just for your medical bills but for everyone's in the pool. Every now and then you break a leg or get cancer and cash in (lucky you), but more often than not, your money and your boss's money go to other people.

Almost no one in America pays his own medical bills. Almost no one can. Only through collective effort, through a mishmash of government and private pools, can most of us financially survive a major medical event.

The next logical step would be to join our patchwork pools into one giant pool to minimize individual risk and maximize coverage. But then Dennis Kucinich and I shout Single-payer!, someone else shouts Collectivism! Socialism! Marxism!, and the plan falls apart. What gives?

America pays for health care primarily by collective means. But Americans cling to an individualist worldview. This individualism runs deep. We think we can solve crime and general moral decline if each of us just packs a gun. We flock to evangelical churches that promise a personal relationship with God and preach that salvation hinges on personal decisions and actions (memo to the faithful: that last part is wrong).

To resolve the cognitive dissonance between our belief in individual efficacy and our reliance in health care on collective efficacy, we trick ourselves. We deliberately compartmentalize, individualize, detach ourselves from the community of policyholders our dollars take care of. If we have employer-based health care, we think strictly in terms of our insurance as a benefit we earn for ourselves through our work. If we buy insurance on the individual market, we probably don't even know the fellow policyholders we support and who support us when we need them (if our insurers don't drop us). And as we get older, we tell ourselves that social support programs are really "my Medicare," as if each of us will simply draw from our own individual pot of money earned strictly by our own labor.

We tell ourselves health care is still all about personal responsibility, although really, from cradle to grave, we buy into a social protection system of our own making that fundamentally rejects individualism. That's cognitive dissonance.

We're like a crazy Malian villager who uses the machine to pound the corn, then claims to have done it all by hand. We've already bought into collective efficacy in health coverage; we just can't admit it. And we just can't admit that a national health insurance system, providing more coverage and more autonomy to more Americans, is not a Marxist revolution but merely the logical extension of a system we already depend on.

We're already our brothers' keepers. Let's do it better with a single-payer system.

Saturday, June 27, 2009

"Dakota" Voice All Apologies for Adulterous Sanford

Bob Ellis cuts-and-pastes an ultra-conservative blog called "Dakota" Voice. On this fundie blog, Ellis has cited adultery as a legitimate reason to...
But when Bob Ellis sees fit to open his mouth about adulterous AWOL South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford, the first words out of his mouth are, "Who Says This Is the End for Mark Sanford?" Parroting Star Parker:

When I’ve been asked whom I thought could be the individual to lead the Republican Party out of the wilderness, my answer has always been Mark Sanford.

His vision for his party and his country — traditional values and limited government — has always been clear, consistent, and, in my view, correct. And he has always pursued that vision, as a congressman and as a governor, with a boldness and courage rare among politicians [Star Parker, reprinted by Bob Ellis, "Dakota"Voice.com, 2009.06.27].

The only words of criticism of Sanford's behavior from Parker/Ellis: "I watched with disappointment his confession about his clandestine adulterous affair." And then we're off to the races, blaming America's moral decline on the Kennedys, Roe v. Wade, and, with tone-deaf hilarity, same-sex marriage:

We move step by definitive step to legalizing same sex marriage. By so doing, we will render our most sacred social institution, marriage, meaningless in the official eyes of government and as a nation will formalize the acceptability of behavior our Bible clearly calls sinful and abominable [Parker/Ellis, 2009.06.27].

You know, you don't do much for the meaning of marriage by running off to Argentina for five days of nothing-left-to-lose sex with your mistress, either.

Dakota War College had the decency to call Governor Sanford's misconduct what it is: "a big whack out of your moral authority" and "a bad example for the GOP." DWC also didn't have to wait three days for its moral compass to find the right words; Mr. Powers knew what to say right away. "Dakota" Voice waits three days after Governor Sanford's public confession to bury its first Sanford commentary, filled with diversion and sugar-coating, on a low-readership Saturday. (But hardly an hour after the media announce Michael Jackson's death, Ellis opines that the King of Pop, with his "sissified manner," has probably gone to hell.)

So who says this is the end for Mark Sanford? How about the conservative (and Moonie-run!) Washington Times, which comes up with a much more apt, direct, no-bull assessment of Governor Sanford's political future... or lack thereof:

...[N]ow he has squandered much of his legacy on an act of pure folly.

His extramarital affair gave his enemies the political rope they needed to hang him finally. Whether or not Mr. Sanford resigns is irrelevant. He is spent as a national political force. His erratic and bizarre behavior - the weird claims that he was hiking on an undisclosed path along the Appalachian Trail; his rambling, confused news conference announcing his infidelity; and the steamy e-mails that have been published on the correspondence between him and his Argentine mistress - have doomed his chances as a Republican presidential contender in 2012. He has become a laughingstock [Jeffrey T. Kuhner, "Corrupt Conservatives: Sanctimonious Hypocrites on the Right Dishonor Faith, Family and Freedom," Washington Times, 2009.06.27].

Bob Ellis likes to accuse me of moral relativism and depravity. Bob Ellis doesn't know me at all. On Mark Sanford's adultery and dereliction of duty, I'm the pinko secular humanist talking moral absolutes: Sanford has demonstrated an emotional instability, immaturity, and inability to keep personal crises from affecting his execution of official duties. (And yes, I would entertain a similar argument about President Bill Clinton's adultery and deception in the White House.) Professed Christian and conservative Bob Ellis is the one making excuses and exemptions... and claiming Sanford could be a great American leader.

--------------------
Update 11:35 CDT: Who else says this should be the end for Sanford?
  • Randy Page, conservative Republican activist and president of South Carolinians for Responsible Government: "In order to best protect and Blogger: Madville Times - Edit Post ""Dakota" Voice All Apologies for Adulterous Sanfor..."preserve his family and the integrity of the Office of Governor, it is necessary for him to resign from office to allow his family, his staff and the people of the Palmetto State time to heal and move forward."
  • Conservative/libertarian-leaning Carolina blogger Bane Windlow, who has been an "ardent" Sanford supporter but now says Sanford "crossed the line by just up and leaving the state for six days. It’s almost akin to a soldier going AWOL while on active duty. That, plus the nature of his sabatical [sic] that has now revealed itself for all intents and purposes have crushed any remaining credibility the man may have left in Columbia." (Windlow's Carolina Politics Online has more than double "Dakota" Voice's readership, according to Quantcast.)
  • Arch-conservative columnist Charles Krauthammer: "The governor of the state is chief executive, and if there is a disaster in the state, and this guy is incommunicado, he is nowhere to be seen and he doesn’t transfer authority to his lieutenant governor who calls out the National Guard, you cannot recover from that. I think he doesn’t last a week in the office of governor."
  • and the list goes on....
------------------------
Update 2009.07.03 11:13 CDT: John Gilgoff, US News's God and Country blogger, finds remarkable the total silence of other family values groups on Mark Sanford's "duplicitousness and breaches of character." Gilgoff quotes conservative faves Tony Perkins and Harry Jackson:

As long as we as Christians are willing to tolerate or overlook duplicity in our self-identified party, it will be clear to the world that our allegiance is to a party and not the truth, regardless of what we claim. . . .

Thursday, June 25, 2009

The Measure of a Man: What He Says to Us... and to His Mistress

What'd you say, Bob?

[I]t is my personal view that the largest proclamation of one’s faith ought to be in how one lives one’s life.

—South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford, quoted by Aaron Leichman of the Christian Post, faithfully regurgitated by Bob Ellis of DakotaVoice.com, 2008.06.06.

One month later...

You have a particular grace and calm that I adore. You have a level of sophistication that so fitting with your beauty. I could digress and say that you have the ability to give magnificent gentle kisses, or that I love your tan lines or that I love the curve of your hips, the erotic beauty of you holding yourself (or two magnificent parts of yourself) in the faded glow of the night's light - but hey, that would be going into sexual details ...

—South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford, e-mail to someone other than his wife, 2008.07.10, published by South Carolina's The State, reprinted by Fox News, 2009.06.25.

For more on hypocrisy, read Steve Hemmingsen's forthright commentary at KELOLand.com. As he says, "the bunch that prays the loudest... often has the most to pray about."

-------------------
p.s.: Fox News says the woman for whom Mark Sanford violated the sanctity of his marriage supposedly works for Bunge Limited, an agribusiness conglomerate that competes with Cargill and Archer Daniels Midland (says Wikipedia). Oh well: another Republican in bed with Big Ag....

-------------------
Update 2009.06.27 09:15 CDT: Predictably, Bob Ellis trots out tripe about Mark Sanford's bold, courageous leadership and "clear, consistent... and correct" vision of "traditional values and limited government." Well, South Carolina certainly got limited government while Sanford was AWOL, but where again is the leadership in abandoning your post for a final fling after your wife throws you out?

Sounds like Dakota Voice is pandering to adulterers.

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Vaclav Havel to Iran: 'Virtue in Working for a Good Cause"

I know better than to believe that the current protests in Iran will lead to some quick Hollywood ending where law and democracy and the good guys win. Hope for the best, but expect Tiananmen Square.

Playwright and former Czech President Vaclav Havel knows a thing or two about fighting what appears to be a losing battle against an oppressive regime. He wrote plays and philosophical tracts that critiqued the Communist regimes of Eastern Europe. He sat in prison for years for his words. And 21 years after seeing the Prague Spring crushed by the Soviet/Warsaw Pact military, he oversaw a bloodless revolution and became president of his country.

Havel offers a few words of encouragement for the Iranian supporters of Mir-Hossein Mousavi who think the Ahmadinejad government is trying to steal the presidential election:

Interviewer: You are well-known and highly respected by many people in Iran. What would you like to say to Iranians directly?

Havel: [I would tell them that] I sympathize with them, that I'm keeping my fingers crossed for them and I would advise them not to fall prey to skepticism if they do not achieve immediate results in spite of their efforts.

These efforts are important in and of themselves because there is virtue in working for a good cause. And these efforts can pay off later, God knows when, God knows how. But you cannot time it. That, at least, is our experience [emphasis mine; interview, "Havel Expresses Solidarity with Iranian Demonstrators," Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 2009.06.15].

Even if your words and deeds do not produce the results—or the regime change—you seek, you do your soul good by fighting the good fight. That's pretty strong idealism.

Havel also recommends a dose of idealism for politicians outside Iran trying to figure out what to say and do:

...expressions of solidarity with those who are defending human rights, with students and others, are important. In general, oil should not be more important than human rights [emphasis mine].

Saturday, May 30, 2009

Can You Get Your Hands Dirty in the Global Economy?

Here are a couple of articles to read side by side. First, last Sunday's New York Times Magazine runs a remarkable essay by Matthew B. Crawford. I should say Dr. Crawford: the author has a Ph. D. in political philosophy from the august University of Chicago. Dr. Crawford's current occupation: he fixes motorcycles. Between Hondas and Harleys, Crawford has managed to write a book, Shop Class as Soul Craft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work. The NYT essay distills the main ideas of the book:
  • Modern "knowledge work" can be more nervating than liberating.
  • Working with one's hands is wrongfully viewed as a sacrifice, a last resort, and a waste of talent.
  • A successful motorcycle mechanic is every bit a scientist and scholar, engaging in at least as much complex thinking, problem-solving, ethical reasoning, and social intelligence as any academic in a university lab or library.
  • Shop work has more genuine utility, integrity, and fun than a lot of cubicle jobs.
Among my favorite lines from Crawford is this observation: "There probably aren't many jobs that can be reduced to rule-following and still be done well." Think Big Macs: no McDonald's employee makes a great Big Mac. Big Mac production is a matter of pushing buttons and responding to timers as dictated by rigorously established standardized procedures. Or think the classroom: those situations where teachers and students are citing and following step-by-step lesson plans or policy manuals are likely the moments when the least genuine learning and personal engagement are happening. The best learning happens when we engage in vigorous conversation and exploration that defies that guidance of written rules.

Crawford also offers this observation about what constitutes a good job:
A good job requires a field of action where you can put your best capacities to work and see an effect in the world. Academic credentials do not guarantee this.

Nor can big business or big government — those idols of the right and the left — reliably secure such work for us. Everyone is rightly concerned about economic growth on the one hand or unemployment and wages on the other, but the character of work doesn’t figure much in political debate. Labor unions address important concerns like workplace safety and family leave, and management looks for greater efficiency, but on the nature of the job itself, the dominant political and economic paradigms are mute. Yet work forms us, and deforms us, with broad public consequences [Matthew B. Crawford, "The Case for Working with Your Hands," New York Times Magazine, 2009.05.24].

Crawford pegs where I experience the disconnect with my Madison neighbors who think landing a call center would be a step up for our town. We want more jobs, steady wages, and good benefits, but we don't have a lot of conversations about the work itself. Forget the paycheck and perks: does your work itself make your soul healthy? Does it help your neighbors? Does it serve your god(s)? How often do we ask those questions... and how often do we instead just shut those questions out of our minds for 8 hours a day?

Crawford sees the economy driving more people to spend their money on repairing what they have rather than just buying more new junk. He is hopeful that the sternly shaken economy will free more people to pursue jobs more oriented to their true callings, whether for management or mechanics.

Perhaps motorcycle repair shops will fare well, but Robert Reich's most recent online essay argues that a lot of other physical jobs are gone for good. The former Labor Secretary argues that trying to save manufacturing jobs at GM and elsewhere is a fool's errand. Productivity gains have caused declines in manufacturing jobs everywhere. Percentage-wise, Japan, Brazil, and our main nemesis China have lost more such jobs than the U.S. has. Machines and computers mean we just don't need as many people to build things any more.

You should be nervous anytime you hear "don't need" and "people" that close together. But Reich says it's inevitable, and we should accept it, just as we did in farming (30% of Americans worked to produce food a hundred years ago; now less than 5% do). Reich lists a number of jobs that technology has replaced and is replacing: elevator operators, telephone operators, bank tellers, gas station attendants, store check-out clerks, travel agents, real estate brokers, stock brokers, and accountants.

Reich says routine jobs—all those jobs Crawford mentioned that can be reduced to rule-following—are disappearing. So what's left for human workers?

A growing percent of every consumer dollar goes to people who analyze, manipulate, innovate and create. These people are responsible for research and development, design and engineering. Or for high-level sales, marketing and advertising. They're composers, writers and producers. They're lawyers, journalists, doctors and management consultants. I call this "symbolic analytic" work because most of it has to do with analyzing, manipulating and communicating through numbers, shapes, words, ideas [Robert Reich, "The Future of Manufacturing, GM, and American Workers (Part I)," Robert Reich's Blog, 2009.05.29].

That's great news for idea-guys like me. If I were my dad, I'd be nervous. My dad was a mechanic in the Army. He has worked for Morrell's, built and painted houses, and now mans an assembly line making plastic widgets at PPD. He hates computers, I think because they have no moving parts, nothing a guy can just look at and understand. But where I spend half an hour using a spreadsheet and trigonometry to figure out the lengths for studs on a shed with an angled roof, he drops a line and cuts.

My intelligence is symbolic-analytic. Dad's is physical-mechanical. His intelligence is every bit as good as mine, and a heck of a lot more useful when we want to dig a basement or fix the mower. But the economy Reich describes favors my intelligence over Dad's intelligence.

Or does it? Are workers spinning the same bolts in the same holes a thousand times a day really using their physical-mechanical intelligence the same way Crawford does in his motorcycle shop? The routine jobs to which Reich says good riddance are mostly mindless; clear them away, and we free those workers—or challenge those workers—to do work that uses their bodies and minds more fully for jobs that mass-production robots can't do, like fixing motorcycles, building houses, or operating a skid-steer.

My dad doesn't have to worry: he's close to retiring. But what about workers like him, for whom a cubicle job would be a spirit-damaging waste of talent? If manufacturing disappears, do we have enough work—not just jobs, not just excuses for paychecks, but real dignified and dignifying work for every one of our neighbors?

Work that gets our hands dirty is important. It allows us to connect mind and body with the physical reality around us, not to mention with the neighbor who needs a motor fixed or a leaky toilet replaced. We need to remember that working with things requires as much knowledge as the vaunted "knowledge work" the academy and economy celebrate. Even if we embrace the economic realities Reich discusses, we must also keep in mind Crawford's message about the value of work as something that builds not just GDP but souls and communities.

Friday, May 1, 2009

Black Hills, White Conquerors, Lakota Values... and the Ferengi?

True freedom-fighters and Lakota traditionalists, feel free to ignore everything I'm about to say. I'm just another White man who lives on land won by lies and force. Any man, Red, White, or otherwise, who tries to take "my" land will be met with every lawyer and shotgun I can afford.

My white conqueror's privilege notwithstanding, Dr. Newquist gets me thinking about the Black Hills and our neighbors the Lakota. Newquist spotlights some remarkable racist commentary from L. Frank Baum, kind and gentle Wizard of Oz author and long-ago editorialist for the Aberdeen Saturday Pioneer:

The PIONEER has before declared that our only safety depends upon the total extirmination [sic] of the Indians. Having wronged them for centuries we had better, in order to protect our civilization, follow it up by one more wrong and wipe these untamed and untamable creatures from the face of the earth. In this lies safety for our settlers and the soldiers who are under incompetent commands. Otherwise, we may expect future years to be as full of trouble with the redskins as those have been in the past [L. Frank Baum, Aberdeen Saturday Pioneer, 1891.01.03, quoted by David Newquist, "The Stolen Black Hills and the Fight to Give Them Back," Northern Valley Beacon, 2009.04.30].

Newquist is putting in perspective a somewhat less genocidal but similarly wrongheaded editorial from this century's descendant of Baum's paper, in which contemporary Aberdonians may read that the Lakota should whore themselves for the money their conquerors say is fair compensation for the stolen Black Hills.

I don't pay as much attention as I ought to Indian issues like the renewed lawsuit over the Black Hills. Neither it seems, does most of the South Dakota media, mainstream or otherwise. I suspect we find it uncomfortable to be reminded that our beautiful state is land won through lies and guns. Some history just doesn't look good on the Chamber of Commerce brochures.

The Supreme Court awarded the Tribes of the Great Sioux Nation a financial settlement in 1980 for what Justice Harry Blackmun called the most "ripe and rank case of dishonest dealings" in American history. Yet the tribes haven't touched the money, which now approaches $900M.

How, in a world where everything revolves around money, can the poorest people in America refuse to accept millions of dollars? Because they consider the land that was stolen from them to be sacred and as they say, "One does not sell their Mother" [Tim Giago, "The Black Hills: A Case of Dishonest Dealings," Huffington Post, 2007.06.03].

It's easy to me to opinionate as a member of the privileged conqueror class. I have my land. My Congress will never pass the Bradley Bill or even consider an idea floated by my good friend Greg, who suggested we give all of West River back to the tribes. (Greg was from Minnesota; I can't recall if he was willing to give back the Twin Cities.) No one looks at me with suspicion whenever I pop into town for groceries or a job interview.

But for what it's worth, I sympathize with the position of the tribal members who oppose this new lawsuit. I do my share of putting principle over pragmatism... and that's with much less at stake than nearly a billion dollars and the soul of my people.

The tribal members hiring the Yankton lawyers to prosecute this latest lawsuit represent the pragmatic view: The tribes will never win possession of the Black Hills. The youth are losing their spiritual connection to the land, so we might as well get our money and put it to good use.

Taking that money would not be a victory. It would be a surrender... perhaps the final surrender in a battle long ago lost. It would be a capitulation to the conquerors' view (my culture's view) that everything is for sale, that land is merely a commodity, that a man's worth is not much greater than his bank account.

The folks who say "The Black Hills are not for sale" are idealists. I admire sincere idealists, especially those who put justice over material gain (and one could argue the material gain of taking a one-time lawsuit settlement would be meager and fleeting).

But then the White man saying this isn't hungry or unemployed.

I have long wondered how we would react if some warlike, technologically advanced race—say, Klingons, or perhaps more appropriately for the analogy, the Ferengi—invaded, conquered, and herded us savage Earthlings into a few isolated, low-value patches of real estate. Suppose a hundred years later the conquerors let us file a lawsuit in their alien courts and actually rule in our favor, offering a few million bars of latinum for our trouble. At the same time, the invaders politely decline to dismantle even a single tourist resort or starship refueling outpost on our Mother Earth. How would we respond?

What really matters? How important is place to our sense of identity? How long and against what odds do you keep up the good fight?

And as Black Elk asks, "
How could men get fat by being bad, and starve by being good?"

The renewed lawsuit over the Black Hills calls for soul-searching from all South Dakotans, on the reservations and off.

Saturday, April 4, 2009

Media Mush: KELO Misses Story on Minn. Bullying Bill

KELO offers the best TV news on this side of the state. Against KFSY's hyperventilations and KDLT's... well, KDLTness, that's not high praise.

And there are still too many occasions when my wife and I look at each other at the end of a report and say, "Not a story," or "We just learned nothing."

Case in point: Katie Janssen's story on a bullying bill (SF0971) pending in the Minnesota Senate (more info here and here). We learn nothing about the sponsor of the bill (Sen. Scott Dibble of Minneapolis) or the motivation behind the bill (among other things, to bring school policies in line with the Minnesota Human Rights Act). We don't even get enough information to live up to the KELO headline: "Some Say MN Bullying Bill Unnecessary." Some? Among the obligatorily blurred and cropped shots of students roaming the halls of Pipestone HS (including one ridiculously extended shot of a girl's blue-jeaned backside that might trigger existing harassment policies), we only hear from one person, Superintendent Jim Lentz, who never says SF0971 is unnecessary. Lentz appears to say current policy at Pipestone already covers the bullying addressed in Dibble's bill, but he never says every school in Minnesota has such policies.

Where are the some? Channel 11 in Minneapolis can find them, but not Channel 11 in Sioux Falls. KELO makes the mistake of interviewing a school administrator, a position one reaches in part by being trained to give mellow, uncontroversial answers to the media. KELO thus glances off the issue, missing the real controversy where Minnesota's religious right is portraying human rights and student safety as a mere "pretext" for indoctrination in "homosexuality, homosexual marriage, and unhealthy sexual behaviors among impressionable school children."

But KELO doesn't look for that story. KELO also doesn't seek out Pipestone students or parents who might have their own perspective on the necessity of protecting kids from bullying and the effectiveness of current policies. KELO just gives us a one-minute bowl of mush.

Of course, here I am on the couch not seeking those broader perspectives, either. Oh, wait: what's that comment section for?

Sunday, March 1, 2009

Palin Ties Paul... for Third... Among Conservative Base

Sarah Palin in 2012—yeah, right, say conservatives. At CPAC 2009, the just-concluded gathering of hardcore conservatives (also known as the base the GOP is playing to), Governor Palin placed third in a straw poll that asked attendees whom they would nominate as GOP 2012 Presidential candidate. Full results (in PowerPoint format):
  • Mitt Romney: 20%
  • Bobby Jindal: 14%
  • Ron Paul: 13%
  • Sarah Palin: 13%
  • Newt Gingrich: 10%
  • Mike Huckabee: 7%
  • Mark Sanford: 4%
  • Rudy Giuliani: 3%
  • Tim Pawlenty: 2%
  • Charlie Crist: 1%
  • Undecided: 10%
What? No John Thune?

The big point: Sarah Palin tied with Ron Paul. That means one of two things: Ron Paul has a shot (Madison Libertarians, rejoice!) , or Sarah Palin doesn't.

---------------------
Underview: even the rabid CPACkers may be ready to get off the abortion horse. When participants were asked to name their top two issues, abortion came in fifth, behind shrinking the federal government, reducing spending, the war on terrorism, and lowering taxes. Gun rights comes in #10. Could Obama be driving conservatives to get back to fiscal nuts and bolts? Let's hope so!

The straw poll doesn't represent all conservatives: it actually skewed young, with a big student contingent making up a majority of respondents. But I find it interesting—and encouraging?—to see the youngsters on the other side of the aisle focusing on practical policy issues over the contrived and unproductive culture war.

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Big Boy Toy Show Sponsors Bail on Scarlett Strippers

KELO reports that Schaap's RV TraveLand, Billion Automotive, and Jack's Campers have all pulled out of the Big Boys Toy Show to avoid associating with the exotic dancers from Scarlett O'Hara's Gentlemen's Club whom Backyard Broadcasting planned to have tramping about the event.

It never ceases to amaze me the extent of euphemism surrounding the sex industry. "Exotic dancers"? Come now, let's be honest: they're eye prostitutes. And "gentlemen's club"? Chortle. What is gentle or manly about the clientele of a club featuring live porn?

The businesses bailing on the Big Boys Toy Show are using some honest language. Rachelle Schaap says pulling RV Traveland's sponsorship is about business, not morality:

"We're not trying to make a statement. We're just doing what is right for our business and what we believe in our hearts is the right thing for our employees, our business, and our customers" [Rachelle Schaap, quoted by Ben Dunsmoor, "Sponsors Drop Out; Annual Event Drops Dancers," KELOLand.com, 2009.01.16].

For all Sioux Falls's aspirations to big-city cosmopolitanism, some business owners still read the Sioux Falls market as more small-town South Dakota, where selling with sex just isn't good for business (not to mention your community or your soul). Even a secular humanist like me can feel some relief to know that Sioux Falls isn't quite Las Vegas.

Now if we could just get over all the marekting machismo and trying to convince men that they can compensate for their shortcomings by buying larger, louder toys....

Friday, January 9, 2009

European Leaders Call for New Capitalism

Economic quotes of the day:

Purely financial capitalism has perverted the logic of capitalism. Financial capitalism is a system of irresponsibility and... is amoral. It is a system where the logic of the market excuses everything. [1]

It's a system where wealth goes to the wealthy, where work is devalued, where production is devalued, where entrepreneurial spirit is devalued. [1]

In capitalism of the 21st century, there is room for the state. [2]

—French President Nicolas Sarkozy.

On the need to ground capitalism in "values other than the maximum short-term profit": "The greatest entrepreneur I had the chance to meet was passionate about what he had created, not what he had accumulated." [2]

—former British Prime Minister Tony Blair

[1] "French, German Leaders Call for 'Moralization' of Capitalism," Deutsche-Welle, 2009.01.08.
[2] Emma VanDore, "Sarkozy, Merkel, Blair Call for New Capitalism," AP via Yahoo News, 2009.01.08

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Daschle Will Promote Health Reform and Family Values

Cue the one-note chorus from Colorado Springs...

The Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee, chaired by Ted Kennedy, hears testimony from Health and Human Services Secretary-Nominee Tom Daschle today. This isn't a confirmation hearing, but it signals the high priority that both Congress and the Obama Administration plan to give to serious health care reform this year.

The prominence of health care on Washington's radar even in the midst of the economic mess should give hope to many Americans (the uninsured, those facing bankruptcy from medical bills, those of us with high-deductible plans that don't cover maternity...).

Leave it to Focus on the Family to try taking everyone's eyes off the ball. Denise Ross (who has some medical bills coming up soon—congratulations and best wishes for a smooth delivery, Denise!) points us toward a screed from the Dobson wolf-PAC exhorting voters to call the senators on the HELP committee and tell them to vote against Daschle's nomination. "Tom Daschle is a disaster appointment," says blogger Jill Stanek in the post. "Daschle ardently supports abortion... and he disdains abstinence education." FotF's Ashley Horne adds, "Citizens who care about family values should be concerned about Daschle's nomination."

Family values? I got your family values right here. While Jom Dobson's minions bloviate, Joe and Missy Urbaniak are fighting to pay their son Cooper's medical bills. Doctors have removed brain and spine tumors from the three-year-old boy, and now say he needs high-dose chemo and a stem-cell transplant. Cost; $400,000. Their insurer, Sanford Health Plan, is refusing to pay for the treatment, saying it's "experimental." A similar treatment worked for a Wisconsin boy, whose family also had to take their insurer to court to get coverage (the family won). The Urbaniaks' lawyer, Mike Abourezk, notes Sanford appears to be doing a selective reading of the medical studies on the treatment, citing only the parts that uphold their rejection [details in "Family Fights for Boy's Cancer Care," Mitchell Daily Republic, 2009.01.07].

Tom Daschle is coming to Washington to work on health care reform that would help Cooper Urbaniak and millions of other Americans get affordable health care without having to take big corporations to court. That sounds like a focus on the family to me. But you won't hear a word about that from the one-note chorus from Colorado Springs.

Jill Stanek claims, "The only reason Obama appointed Daschle was to assure Obama’s radical support of the abortion industry would be extended through HHS." That's absurd. But Focus on the Family needs to believe that absurdity. The radical right must cast every government action as part of a war on family values; otherwise, their raison d'être (and raison de fundraising) disappears.

Part of me wishes Jim Dobson would just accept his irrelevance. But another part me hopes he keeps up the nuttery. The more Focus on the Family brays, the more Americans will see the difference between fighting a contrived culture war (that's Dobson's need) and solving practical policy problems (that's Obama and Daschle's plan).

If you really value families, call your senators, and tell them to give two thumbs up to Tom Daschle and health care reform.

------------
Update 10:47 CST: Obama didn't pick Daschle because of abortion. He picked Daschle because Daschle knows how to pass legislation. See this smart piece by Carrie Budoff Brown, "Daschle's Approach: Anything But Clinton," in today's Politico.com.

Thursday, November 6, 2008

President-Elect Obama: We Share Lincoln's Values

Some commenters and bloggers living in Wah-Wah Land need some reminders. Here are some highlights from President-Elect Barack Hussein Obama's election night speech:

There will be setbacks and false starts. There are many who won't agree with every decision or policy I make as president. And we know the government can't solve every problem.

But I will always be honest with you about the challenges we face. I will listen to you, especially when we disagree. And, above all, I will ask you to join in the work of remaking this nation, the only way it's been done in America for 221 years - block by block, brick by brick, calloused hand by calloused hand.

...So let us summon a new spirit of patriotism, of responsibility, where each of us resolves to pitch in and work harder and look after not only ourselves but each other.

Let's remember that it was a man from this state who first carried the banner of the Republican Party to the White House, a party founded on the values of self-reliance and individual liberty and national unity.

Those are values that we all share. And while the Democratic Party has won a great victory tonight, we do so with a measure of humility and determination to heal the divides that have held back our progress.

As Lincoln said to a nation far more divided than ours, we are not enemies but friends. Though passion may have strained, it must not break our bonds of affection.

And to those Americans whose support I have yet to earn, I may not have won your vote tonight, but I hear your voices. I need your help. And I will be your president, too [emphasis mine; President-Elect Barack Hussein Obama, election night speech in Grant Park, Chicago, 2008.11.04].

America needs solutions. President-Elect Obama has some, but he knows the best solutions will come from us. He's ready to listen and ready to work. Are you?

-----------------
p.s.: And don't forget: your next President has got game. See S.L. Price's Sports Illustrated account of a little one-on-one with Obama last December on the YMCA court in Spencer, Iowa.

Thursday, July 17, 2008

New Pro-Choice SD Website Impervious to Prayer?

Kelsey at DakotaWomen draws my attention to the irony of the morning: as Burnnie the Bunny (that's the only name on the website) calls on readers to pray for God to "send confusion in the camps of the enemy," NARAL Pro-Choice SD launches a new website that appears to work just fine. Maybe those prayers ricocheted and landed on someone else's new computer system.

Now just like Jim Dobson, I'm not a theologian. But isn't asking the Lord to put the whammy on people you don't like a little unChristian? Maybe the Vote Yes for Life folks would make more progress if they shed their macho bull rhetoric of warfare and enemies and focused a little more on love and community.

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

Citizenship and Community: More Than Market

Kudos to Mr. Epp—actually, to Mr. Epp's dad—for eloquently capturing another reason to be wary of Hyperion's refinery promises at Elk Point. Todd isn't ready to condemn the project, but his dad can point to excellent examples of Big Oil failing to act as good corporate citizens:

“You know, in Aurora, Nebraska (the county seat of the county he grew up in), they have a beautiful new hospital, nursing home, museum, and a library twice as big as we have here in Augusta.

“The oil companies and refineries left nothing for Augusta and El Dorado. They just took and took and took and gave nothing back” [Todd Epp's dad, quoted by Todd in "What Kind of Corporate Citizen Will Hyperion Be?" SD Watch, 2008.07.08].

Some of the apologists for Big Oil and corporate greed who comment here seem to think that the only virtue a business (or an individual) needs to exercise is to work hard in its own capitalist self-interest. Such "market fundamentalism" leads not just to towns lacking public facilities, but also to (as Fred Block puts it) "weak economic performance, corporate crime waves, government corruption and a coarsening of the culture."

Adam Smith said markets work that way, but even Smith recognized that (Block again) "sustainable prosperity must be built on strong moral foundations." And no, "strong moral foundations" doesn't mean villainizing homosexuals and promiscuous women; it means building a sustainable moral economy ("moral economy"—not an oxymoron!) on principles of "reciprocity, responsible competition, conservation, and cooperation" (Block). Cooperation—in other words, seeing your business (and yourself) not as some autonomous atom, unbonded, free to do whatever you want, but as an entity rooted in and obligated to its community.

The oil barons of Kansas apparently focused entirely on profit and competition, to the detriment of the communities from which they extracted that profit. If oil barons come to South Dakota, let's hope they see our communities as more than markets.

Read more: the quotes above come from Fred Block, "Creating a Moral Economy," The Nation, 2006.03.21. reprinted by Alternet.org.

Friday, May 9, 2008

Navy Vet Calls for Department of Peace

There must be something about Lake Herman that turns old warriors into doves. My neighbor Gerald Lange served in the Air Force and now is a strong peace advocate. Another neighbor, Charles Stoneback, was a U.S. Navy Captain in charge of nuclear missiles who now advocates Dennis Kucinich's legislation (HR 808) to create a Department of Peace and Nonviolence. Maybe Jimmy Carter should bring Hamas and the Israeli government to Lake Herman for a weekend. Maybe Howard Dean could bring Clinton and Obama to settle the nomination...

But anyway, Capt. Stoneback got the following letter published in that Sioux Falls paper* a couple weeks ago. I am happy to reprint it here as a yet another fine product of the Lake Herman Brain Trust (that's Lake Herman for you: seat of elitist radicalism that might save the world).

House Bill HR 808 would create a Department of Peace and Nonviolence. The primary function will be to research, articulate and facilitate nonviolent solutions to domestic and international conflict. This bill to date has 68 cosponsors but unfortunately our Rep Herseth-Sandlin is not among them.

Although I am a retired U. S, Navy Captain who has spent many years in the submarine launched ballistic missile program I have become convinced in later years that neither war or the spending on our vast military industrial complex have made us a safer or richer nation. Our Civil War left a half million combatants dead but it wasn’t until the active nonviolent movement of Martin Luther King that our black citizens achieved a degree of equality. World War I was to end all wars but severe war reparations on Germany led to the rise of Hitler and an even deadlier war. The power of active nonviolence was proven most effective in two other post World War II situations. The first was Gandhi”s active nonviolent march in removing the British from India. The second was active nonviolence by Polish shipyard workers as well as citizens of East Berlin and Czechoslovakia and finally Russia in ending the Cold War. We claimed it was a just war in Viet Nam to save the world from Communism and another just war in Iraq to eliminate weapons of mass destruction. In Viet Nam our defeat resulted in a nationalistic independent nation and I suspect the same will happen in Iraq. Unfortunately we leave hundreds of thousands of collateral dead in addition to precious blood of our youth and trillions of dollars in debt to burden future generations.

Is it not worth spending a small portion of our defense budget to explore nonviolent solutions to conflict? If you agree, ask Rep. Herseth-Sandlin to sign on to the Department of Peace bill and to ask Senators Thune and Johnson to introduce a similar bill in the Senate.

Seems to me peace and nonviolence are pro-life issues. Maybe if South Dakotans would stop obsessing over sex and making women second-class citizens, we could make some real progress toward making life better (and longer!) for our soldiers and for people around the world.

Friday, May 2, 2008

Anti-Intellectualism: The Perverse Elitism

Ben Stein has struck me as an intelligent individual. His commentaries on economics on American Public Media's Marketplace have struck me as generally well reasoned.

But SD Moderate directs our attention toward the kind of loony anti-intellectualism that shows Ben Stein is just another Hollywood actor trading in celebrity and sound bites. (Conservatives like to dish that line out about actors who advocate causes like electric cars and saving whales; it seems fair to apply the same attack to actors preaching the radical right-wing gospel, don't you think?)

National Review Online's blog excerpts an interview on the Trinity Broadcasting Network, in which the erstwhile erudite Stein boils down thousands of years of scientific progress into a single sentence: "Science leads you to killing people."

Right. Tell that to the folks in med school, or the architects designing earthquake-resistant buildings.

Actually, it all makes sense now: Ben Stein's performances in Ferris Bueller's Day Off and The Wonder Years were part of a quiet crusade to make education look fatally boring. Telling us science is about killing people fits right in.

Stein's rant echoes the absurd anti-intellectualism that some of our elected officials engage in to rationalize their failed policies. Kelsey at DakotaWomen points us toward a Daily Show clip that makes fun of the failed federal abstinence-only sex education policy. The segment includes this all too real quote from Rep. John Duncan of Tennessee, who responded to the testimony of health education experts before Congress Wednesday with the following:

It seems rather elitist to me for people who maybe have degrees in this field to feel that they, because they've studied, that somehow they know better than the parents.

"Elitist" must be the new orange for Republicans looking to dress up ignorance as principle. Duncan appears to join Stein in a perverse elitism of their own. They seem to be saying, "We don't know as much as others. We aren't experts. We don't get how the world works. Therefore, we are superior."

I thought the whole point of getting an education was to improve oneself. I thought having a degree was something to be proud of.

But maybe (and here's the Madville Times sweping generalization of the morning) this anti-intellectualism explains the dismal state of funding for education in South Dakota. Maybe our Republican governor and elected officials don't really think science and degrees are that important. If science brings money (high-income workers, federal research grants) to South Dakota, great. But education itself? The general public getting enlightened? Oh no, can't have that. Education is just for snooty elitists who want to kill people.

If we want our kids to excel in school, if we want them to beat the Chinese and Koreans on math and science tests, we need to tell them education matters. Comments like those from Stein and Duncan can only encourage kids to tune out their teachers and revel in their ignorance.

--------------------------------
Update 2008.05.12 09:35 CDT:
Read Stanley Crouch's excellent commentary -- "'Elitist' Tag Knocks Education" -- on the value of education and the nonsense of crying "elitism!" at experts.